VH1’s Metal Fatigue

A typical '80s metal image

In 1985, when I loved heavy metal, the only time I could hear it on the radio was once a week at midnight on Metal Shop ( “M-m-m-m-m-m-m-m-m-m-m-m-m-m-m-m-metal shop”), and the only place to watch the videos were the UHF station U68 and the occasional clip in Friday Night Videos.  Both late at night.  This was all pre-cable in Brooklyn, New York, and obviously pre-DVR.  To hear new metal, I’d often chance a record based on the cover alone.  I first heard Metallica that way, which remains my major coup. Savatage, not so much.   Yet now, far, far past the point when I need it, everything on VH1 is coming up metal: Metal Mania, That Metal Show, the million-part documentary Metal Evolution, the preponderance of Iron Maiden and Metallica and miscellaneous metal movies, and Megadeth et al Behind the Music episodes. 

It’s all too much, too late.

Nevertheless, I’m watching it, and more often than not I’m surprised by what I’m seeing, despite my vague, dream-like glimpses of memories of having seen them before.  The majority of the 1980s metal videos, it turns out, featured futuristic apocalyptic Road Warrior sets—sometimes, oddly enough, accompanied by laser guns and flying saucers; at other times, also oddly enough, accompanied by faux-Renaissance Faire swords and scepters—where the only remnants of the present-day to survive are guitars and, apparently, Aquanet.  Crucially, most videos also feature some kind of bondage, chains, cages, or imprisonment scenario, usually with the band itself incarcerated, although sometimes hot chicks in strategically ripped clothing are, apparently, detained for questioning as well.  The best worst example is Queensryche’s “Queen of the Reich” video, which gets everything right.  Which is to say everything wrong.  “LOL” has become a cliché, but just try not to laugh out loud.

I get the end of the world angle.  This was the ’80s, with the endgame of the Cold War (which of course we didn’t know at the time), The Day After and the trauma dramas on TV, Mad Max and War Games at the movies, the official red carpet entrance of crack, AIDS, eating disorders, and drive-by shootings into the public lexicon and consciousness.  The videos?  Mere trickle down dystopia.  Metal was anti-authority, and no civilization just meant no rules and less clothing.  Let college rock feel fine about the end of the world as we know it; to metal bands and fans, it was fuckin’ awesome.

But this bondage business nags me. Dokken’s Breakin’ the Chains (above image) pretty much sums it up, but Def Leppard’s quasi-crucifixion in Foolin’, The Scorpions’ cages and containers in Rock You Like a Hurricane, Quiet Riot’s and Megadeth’s straightjackets and padded cells, Metallica’s electric chairs and hospital beds, and too many more to name: everyone is trapped, confined, restricted, or in somebody else’s power.  I suppose it’s the oldest and most reliable story in existence, the Master Plot of master plots: tension, release; rising action, climax; loss, regain; conflict, resolution.  But the song does not remain the same.  The images—the chains—do.  Yes, they all break free by the end of the clip.  But first they need to be tied up or tied down. 

I guess there were some now-obvious but at the time (to me) unconscious fetishes at work, but the emotional metaphors trump the sexual ones.  In retrospect, there is the inescapable sense of the inescapable, despite that they—we—were white, and straight, and male, and socially unconstrained, irresponsible in the best sense, and at the height of youth, strength, and beauty.  Yet in the metal videos, all anyone felt were the metal restraints; all they saw were the bars of their metal cages.

The images seem funny and maybe ironic now, even though I felt and identified with the music at the time in a visceral, animal way.  And I’d say that they were funny, except for commercials that punctuate them as they air on VH1 now: a steady stream of Technicolor desperation, ad after ad for credit checks, mortgage and bankruptcy help, baldness cures and hair restoration, and something ominously called the PosTVac, which aims to restore losses of, um, other kinds. 

Popular culture to the contrary, the world didn’t end in the 1980s after all, as it turned out.  For metal fans, something much worse happened: it went on.   And life had much heavier things in store.  If you thought you were in chains and cages then, twenty plus years later, you’ve got another thing coming.

But I get to watch all the metal I want now.

Time: fifty-five goddamn depressing minutes. 

Coming soon:  Darwin, Hegel, Francis Fukiyama, PBS, Ken Burns, and Ozzy Osborne: welcome to the unlikely mash-up that is the documentary Metal Evolution.

UPDATE 2/8/12: Read the Metal Evolution post: VH1’s Metal Evolution as Interpreted by Theorists other than Charles Darwin

Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

3 thoughts on “VH1’s Metal Fatigue

  1. jkavadlo says:

    A comment thread broke out on Facebook, which I’ve copied here:

    Tom Cassidy I think whats going on now is the fact that we are the forty year olds who were telling us about Max’s Kansas City and Joplin…Except our stories are about L’amour and White Lion (who?)

    Jesse Kavadlo Yes. Thanks for reading. White Lion showed up for literally one second in Metal Evolution as an unnamed example of the bands that killed glam. I also mentioned you by name in my last post, “No Gym Lockers to Narnia”! You’re famous.

    Tom Cassidy lol…..i saw that metal evolution….had to rewind for a minute just to see them unnamed. at least they were using a clip from the old L’amour dressing room

    Danny Kavadlo Metal evolution is awesome. I think you’re being a little hard on VH1. And metal. Are metal images of the 80’s really an sillier than Marilyn Manson in the 90’s (fake blood, tits)? Or slipnot (clown mask and fake noses) in the 00’s? Or Lady Gaga (alien prosthetics and a million other things) today? C’mon, they all look ridiculous. I wanna laugh at some of the shit I see out there now. I can’t think of a current band that has half the gumption, attitude, and, yes, songwriting and live prowess as Motley Crue. And don’t forget: it was all things 80’s (not just metal) that were over-the-top. Whooo… I feel better now. How has Vincent Morrone not weighed in on this yet?

    Tom Cassidy ‎Danny Kavadlo…how do you facebook while human flag-ing?

    Vincent Morrone I haven’t had time to really look at this. I watch VH1 classics sometimes. There was a lot of junk back in the 80’s, but there was a lot of great music. I think Danny Kavadlo makes some very good points. Great music is great music, but there’s nothing wrong with dressing up if you like. Let’s face it, if I managed to get in a band at my age and had the best songs ever, I’d still want to put on a show. Good luck getting my fat ass into spandex, but my point stands.

    Jesse Kavadlo Vinnie–read it! Dan, thanks for reading and commenting. You’re right about everything, but I don’t feel anything for or identify with the other stuff, so it’s easier for me to give it a shrug. The blog post is less about metal’s flaws than my retroactive understanding of its imagery. I also agree with you about Motley Crue, which is something I’m going to write about re: Metal Evolution, where Sam Dunn was openly and unfairly, I thought, biased against glam. More later.

    Tom Cassidy completely biased against glam…..first words of the documentary were “i grew up hating these guys but it was important so im gonna find out about them ”

    Johnny O’Reilly Well done. You need to say all that on That Metal Show.

    Danny Kavadlo He was biased against glam, BUT… the Crue and Quiet Riot were pretty well represented. I would like to see Vinnie in spandex on That Metal Show. You gotta love Eddie Trunk, who without a trace of irony or silliness, is truly interested in current, non-nostalgic projects from guys like Mike Monroe and Ripper Owens.

    Tom Cassidy yea if he wouldnt talk so much hed b great

    Al Kavadlo Brilliant analysis, Jesse! I really loved this blog, though I also agree with Danny’s counterpoints (as well as your counter-counter points). All in all a good discussion. You should submit this piece to a magazine. Does Hit Parader still exist?

    Jesse Kavadlo Thanks, Johnny O. Thanks, Al. I’ve been really happy with everything so far, even as I’m still figuring out what if anything I’m going to do with the blog entries, either individually or as they accumulate. Not sure if That Metal Show or Hit Parader wants any actual critical analysis. PS to Vinnie: you missed one about zombies last week.

    Danny Kavadlo Yeah Tommy, eddie trunk should talk less. I remember him as a dj on 102.7. He’s still got a great look for radio.

    Johnny O’Reilly Vh1 has 7 hours of metal lined up right now.

  2. I’m allowing this pingback, but I think it’s from some content farm and I have no idea what purpose it serves. If anyone knows how this works or what this site is, let me know.
    […] VH1’s Metal Fatigue « HourmanDec 22, 2011 … Yet now, far, far past the point when I need it, everything on VH1 is coming up … This was the ’80s, with the endgame of the Cold War (which of … […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: